Theft of Movable Property Lawyer in Hudson County

Reviewed by William A. Proetta, Esq. · Updated October 2026

Theft of movable property, the charge New Jersey uses for taking something that belongs to someone else, is a violation of N.J.S.A. 2C:20-3(a) and is graded under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(b) by the fair market value of what was taken: under $200 is a disorderly persons offense, $200 to $500 is a fourth-degree crime carrying up to 18 months, more than $500 is third degree with three to five years of exposure, and $75,000 or more is second degree with a presumption of state prison. Certain property is third degree no matter what it is worth, including anything taken directly from a person and a package delivered to a residence. A disorderly persons theft stays in the town’s municipal court, Jersey City Municipal Court at 365 Summit Avenue or Hoboken Municipal Court at 100 Newark Street. An indictable theft is screened by the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office and, if charged, goes to the Criminal Division of Superior Court in the Frank J. Guarini Justice Complex at 24 Central Avenue.

In Hudson County this charge most often means a phone, a bicycle or e-bike, a package from a lobby, or a dispute between roommates or former partners over who owned what. I have defended these cases for more than 15 years. They turn on whether the State can prove the value on the complaint and whether it can prove you meant to keep the property. William Proetta Criminal Law is at 242 10th Street in Jersey City; call (201) 793-8018 any hour for a free case review.

Theft by Unlawful Taking Under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-3

The State must prove three things beyond a reasonable doubt: that you took, or exercised unlawful control over, movable property; that it belonged to someone else; and that you acted with purpose to deprive the owner of it. “Deprive” means to withhold property permanently, or long enough that a substantial portion of its value is lost, or to dispose of it so the owner is unlikely to recover it. Borrowing a neighbor’s bike for an afternoon without asking is not theft of movable property, though it may be unlawful taking of a means of conveyance under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-10, covered on our auto theft page.

Because New Jersey consolidated every form of theft into one offense under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(a), a complaint that says “unlawful taking” can be proven at trial as theft by deception or receiving stolen property, so long as you had fair notice. Takings that are part of one scheme can be aggregated into a single higher-grade count.

Grading: What Makes Theft a Fourth, Third or Second Degree Crime

Value means fair market value at the time and place of the theft (N.J.S.A. 2C:1-14(m)), and the jury must find the dollar range beyond a reasonable doubt. A three-year-old iPhone is not worth its original price. The per se categories matter most in two Hudson County situations. A phone or wallet lifted from a pocket on the PATH or the light rail is theft from the person and third degree even at $150. A package taken from an apartment-building doorstep or vestibule is covered if a cargo carrier delivered it to a residence and its value is under $75,000 or undetermined, so a $20 box pulled from a lobby on doorbell-camera footage produces an indictable complaint.

Theft of movable property: value sets the grade, but some property is third degree at any value

N.J.S.A. 2C:20-3, graded under 2C:20-2(b). Bars span the ordinary prison range on a 0 to 10 year scale.

AmountGradePrison exposureCourt
Breach of a fiduciary duty, $50,000 or moreunder $50,000 is third degree
Second degree
fine up to $150,000 · presumption of prison
Superior Court
$75,000 or more
Second degree
fine up to $150,000 · presumption of prison
Superior Court
From the person, a firearm, boat, airplane, pet, credit or debit card, prescription blank, public record or delivered packageper se categories
Third degree
fine up to $15,000 · presumption against prison, first offender
Superior Court
Over $500, under $75,000
Third degree
fine up to $15,000 · presumption against prison, first offender
Superior Court
$200 to $500
Fourth degree
fine up to $10,000 · presumption against prison, first offender
Superior Court
Under $200
Disorderly persons
fine up to $1,000
Municipal court
02.557.510 yrs
What was taken can matter more than what it was worth. A $40 phone lifted from a person’s hand is a third-degree crime, not a municipal court matter, and force changes it again into robbery under N.J.S.A. 2C:15-1.

Indictable offenses are screened by the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office before the Criminal Division of Superior Court (24 Central Avenue, Jersey City) hears them.

Property that is an indictable crime no matter what it is worth

N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(b)(1)–(2). For these categories the dollar value does not set the grade; a $20 item is still a third-degree crime in Superior Court.

Second degree at any value
Extortion · fiduciary breach of $50,000 or more
Five to ten years with a presumption of prison. Extortion by threat of injury, restraint or another offense (2C:20-5(a)) also carries 85% parole ineligibility under NERA; other extortion does not.
Third degree at any value
Firearm
Any gun, loaded or not.
Third degree at any value
Boat, vessel, horse, airplane
Includes a kayak or dinghy from a Hoboken or Jersey City marina.
Third degree at any value
Pet
A “domestic companion animal.”
Third degree at any value
New Jersey Prescription Blank
The official blank, not the medication.
Third degree at any value
Credit, debit or access card
Also a defaced access device. Use of the card is charged separately under 2C:21-6.
Third degree at any value
Public record or filed instrument
Court files, deeds, government records.
Third degree at any value
Delivered package from a residence
A parcel left by a cargo carrier at a home, under $75,000 or of undetermined value.
Third degree at any value
Taken from the person
A wallet from a pocket or a phone from a hand, with no force on the person.
Third degree at any value
Breach of a fiduciary duty, under $50,000
Trustee, agent, guardian, bookkeeper.
Third degree at any value
By threat not amounting to extortion
A threat that falls outside the 2C:20-5 list.
Third degree: 3 to 5 years, fine up to $15,000Second degree: 5 to 10 years, fine up to $150,000

A first offender charged in the third degree starts with a presumption against prison (N.J.S.A. 2C:44-1(e)); that presumption does not apply in the second degree. Motor vehicles are no longer on this list; since 2023 they are charged under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-10.1.

Sentencing and Collateral Penalties

Restitution is mandatory under N.J.S.A. 2C:44-2(b) when the owner suffered a loss and you can pay, and the fine may be set at up to double the value taken under N.J.S.A. 2C:43-3. Below $75,000 the sentencing presumptions on our theft and fraud hub apply. A theft conviction also shows up in screening for jobs that handle money or confidential records, which is a reason to aim for a diversion or dismissal rather than a plea.

Theft Charges in Jersey City, Hoboken and Hudson County

The volume in Hudson County is bikes, e-bikes, scooters and phones. A bike cut from a rack on Washington Street or outside the Grove Street PATH produces a complaint whose grade depends on what the owner says it cost, and an e-bike can push a case over the $500 line. Phones taken from bar tables, gym lockers and rideshares are the next category. Tracking apps often put the phone at an address within hours, so the State’s case may rest on possession alone. That brings in the permissive inference from recent, unexplained possession (State v. Burch, 179 N.J. Super. 336 (App. Div.), certif. denied, 89 N.J. 396 (1981)), which never shifts the burden, and the judge must say so.

The other recurring case is the ownership dispute: a former partner who kept the television, a roommate who took the furniture when the lease ended, an employee who kept a company laptop. These are often disorderly persons complaints signed by the complainant rather than the police, heard in Jersey City Municipal Court or Hoboken Municipal Court, and they turn on the claim-of-right defense below. Where the complainant is a current or former household member, the complaint may arrive with a temporary restraining order, and the theft case and the domestic violence matter have to be handled together.

Indictable complaints go to the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office for screening, where a fourth-degree phone or bike theft can be downgraded and remanded to municipal court or routed to Pretrial Intervention before any grand jury presentation.

Diversion Choices in a Theft Case

The eligibility rules for Pretrial Intervention and conditional dismissal are set out on our theft and fraud hub. What matters on this charge is that grade and diversion track each other. A $150 phone taken from a pocket is third degree and indictable only because of the per se category, so the first negotiation is whether the facts support a taking from the person at all. Winning that point moves the case to municipal court and to the lighter program.

Arrest and Pretrial Release

Most theft of movable property cases begin with a summons, not an arrest. When police do arrest, usually because the property was tracked to an address or the charge falls in a per se category, Pretrial Services makes a release recommendation at the first appearance. Open cases or a history of failing to appear are what push a plain theft toward a detention request.

Immigration Consequences of a Theft Conviction

A theft sentence of one year or more, including a suspended one, is generally treated as an aggravated felony under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(43)(G). For a non-citizen the working rule on this charge is to keep every count below 365 days. A disorderly persons theft, with its six-month maximum, can fit the petty-offense exception; a fourth-degree conviction cannot. The moral turpitude analysis is on the hub.

Defenses to Theft of Movable Property

  • Claim of right. An honest belief that the property was yours, that you had a right to take it, or that the owner would have consented is an affirmative defense under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(c), and it is not limited to a belief in outright ownership. The jury must be instructed on it whenever the evidence supports it (State v. Ippolito, 287 N.J. Super. 375 (App. Div. 1996)). It does not extend to taking property by force: collecting a debt with your hands is robbery (State v. Mejia, 141 N.J. 475 (1995)).
  • No purpose to deprive. Temporary use, an intent to return the item, or a misunderstanding over a loan negates the mental state. Where the defendant admits taking the property and claims a right to it, the unexplained-possession inference is inappropriate (Ippolito).
  • Value. The State must prove fair market value, not replacement cost. Purchase records and comparable listings the complainant never produced can drop a case below $500 or $200.
  • Theft, not robbery. When a purse or phone snatch is charged as robbery, the line is whether force was used against the person beyond what was needed to take the property (State v. Sein, 124 N.J. 209, 217-18 (1991)). A snatch from a bag without a struggle is third-degree theft from the person, not a second-degree robbery.
  • How the property was found. A phone tracked to an apartment does not authorize police to enter it. A warrantless entry or a pressured consent search supports a motion to suppress everything recovered.

Theft of Movable Property FAQs

What is theft of movable property in New Jersey?

Taking or exercising control over someone else’s property with purpose to deprive them of it, under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-3(a). It covers everything from a phone to a bicycle to cash, and it is graded by value.

Is stealing a bike a felony in New Jersey?

It depends on fair market value. Under $200 is a disorderly persons offense in municipal court; $200 to $500 is fourth degree; over $500, which can include an e-bike, is a third-degree crime in Superior Court.

What is “theft from the person”?

Taking property directly from someone’s body or clothing, such as a phone from a pocket on the PATH. It is third degree regardless of value, and if force is used against the person it becomes robbery.

Is taking a package off a porch a crime in NJ?

Yes. Theft of a package delivered by a carrier to a residence is a third-degree crime under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(b) regardless of what was inside.

Can I be charged with theft for keeping something that was partly mine?

You can be charged, but an honest claim of right is an affirmative defense under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2(c), and it is the central issue in disputes between former partners or roommates.

What if my ex filed both a theft complaint and a restraining order?

The two proceed on separate tracks, and what you say in one can surface in the other. The theft complaint and the domestic violence matter should be handled together, with the claim-of-right facts in view from the first hearing.

Talk to a Hudson County Theft Lawyer

Whether the property was a phone, a bike or a package, the questions are the same: what it was worth, whether you meant to keep it and how the police found it. Bring the complaint, any messages with the owner and receipts for the item, and call William Proetta Criminal Law at (201) 793-8018 for a free, confidential review.