Robbery Attorney in Elizabeth, NJ
Reviewed by William A. Proetta, Esq. · Updated November 2026
Robbery under N.J.S.A. 2C:15-1 is a theft, or attempted theft, that involves force, a threat or fear of immediate bodily injury. It is a second-degree crime, and it becomes first degree if the person attempts to kill someone, purposely inflicts or attempts serious bodily injury, or is armed with or threatens to use a deadly weapon. Both grades fall under the No Early Release Act. In Union County, robbery charges are prosecuted by the Union County Prosecutor’s Office in Superior Court in Elizabeth.
What Turns a Theft Into a Robbery
Under the robbery statute, a person commits robbery if, in the course of committing a theft, they:
- inflict bodily injury or use force on another person,
- threaten another person with, or purposely put them in fear of, immediate bodily injury, or
- commit or threaten to immediately commit any first- or second-degree crime.
“In the course of committing a theft” is broader than most people expect. It includes conduct during an attempted theft and during immediate flight afterward. That is how a shoplifting case becomes a robbery case: a person leaves a store with merchandise, a loss prevention employee follows, there is a shove or a struggle in the parking lot, and the State charges second-degree robbery. Nothing has to actually be taken. An attempt is enough.
Robbery and Related Charges
| Charge | Statute | Usual grade | Where it is heard |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robbery with force, threat or fear | 2C:15-1(b) | 2nd degree | Superior Court |
| Armed robbery, or robbery with an attempt to kill or cause serious bodily injury | 2C:15-1(b) | 1st degree | Superior Court |
| Carjacking | 2C:15-2 | 1st degree | Superior Court |
| Shoplifting or theft without force | 2C:20-11 or 2C:20-3 | Disorderly persons to 2nd degree | Municipal or Superior |
Penalties for Robbery
The chart below shows the ordinary prison and fine ranges for each degree.
New Jersey Penalties by Grade
| Grade | Court | Jail or prison | Max fine | Severity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Petty disorderly persons | Municipal Court | Up to 30 days | $500 | |
| Disorderly persons | Municipal Court | Up to 6 months | $1,000 | |
| 4th degree | Superior Court | Up to 18 months | $10,000 | |
| 3rd degree | Superior Court | 3 to 5 years | $15,000 | |
| 2nd degree | Superior Court | 5 to 10 years | $150,000 | |
| 1st degree | Superior Court | 10 to 20 years | $200,000 |
Robbery is on the list of crimes covered by the No Early Release Act. A person convicted of first- or second-degree robbery must serve 85% of the prison term before becoming eligible for parole, followed by five years of parole supervision for a first-degree crime or three years for a second-degree crime. If a real firearm was used or possessed during the robbery, the Graves Act can also require a mandatory minimum of one-half of the sentence or 42 months, whichever is greater.
“Armed” does not always mean a gun. A knife, a bat or any object used or threatened as a deadly weapon can raise the charge to first degree. In New Jersey, a BB or pellet gun can also count; see our page on BB and pellet gun charges.
Where Robbery Charges Come From in Union County
Many Union County robbery charges start in retail areas: The Mills at Jersey Gardens and the shopping corridors of Elizabeth, the stores along Route 22 in Union Township, and shopping centers in Linden. Others involve a phone or wallet taken during a fight on the street in Plainfield or Rahway, or a sale arranged online that goes wrong when the buyer and seller meet in person.
Most robbery arrests lead to a complaint-warrant and a stay at the Union County jail while Pretrial Services prepares a risk assessment. In more serious cases, the prosecutor can file a motion for pretrial detention, and the detention hearing becomes the first major fight in the case.
Robbery or Theft From the Person?
The line between robbery and theft is the force used against a person, not against the property. In State v. Sein, 124 N.J. 209 (1991), the New Jersey Supreme Court held that suddenly snatching a purse from someone’s grasp, with no struggle, injury or threat, is not enough force for robbery. Robbery requires more force than it takes simply to grab the item. A struggle over the property, a shove or a punch can cross that line. A quick grab usually does not.
That distinction changes the whole case. A theft taken directly from another person’s body or grasp is generally a third-degree theft, not a second-degree robbery. A third-degree charge is not covered by the No Early Release Act, does not carry a presumption of prison for a first offender, and keeps Pre-Trial Intervention available on ordinary terms. The same is true when a store employee was bumped or brushed past during a shoplifting stop rather than pushed or struck.
The force or threat also has to happen “in the course of” the theft, which includes the attempt and the immediate flight. Force used after the theft was complete and the flight had ended is a separate assault question, not robbery.
Detention, PTI and Expungement in Robbery Cases
Because robbery is a crime of violence, the prosecutor often asks the court to keep the person in jail until trial. That detention hearing, usually within days of the arrest, is the first major fight. The judge looks at the Pretrial Services risk assessment, the strength of the evidence and the person’s record and ties to the community.
Pre-Trial Intervention is difficult in a robbery case. For a first- or second-degree charge, the prosecutor must consent before an application can be considered, and the PTI statute requires a guilty plea, held in inactive status, before admission. A robbery conviction also can never be expunged. Robbery is on the list of offenses in N.J.S.A. 2C:52-2 that are permanently barred from expungement. A downgrade to theft or simple assault is often the only way to keep a path to a clean record open.
Defending a Robbery Charge
- Was there force or a threat during the theft? If the force came after the theft was over, or there was no threat of immediate bodily injury, the case may be a theft or shoplifting charge, not robbery.
- Was there really a weapon? Whether an object was a deadly weapon, or whether a person was actually armed, decides first versus second degree.
- Identification. Stranger robberies often rest on a quick look, a photo array or grainy video. Identification procedures can be challenged when they were suggestive or unreliable.
- Intent to steal. A fight over money or property that the person believed they were owed raises questions about whether there was a theft at all.
- Statements and searches. Confessions and evidence found in a car or phone can sometimes be suppressed.
A downgrade from robbery to theft, shoplifting or simple assault removes the No Early Release Act and can change the case entirely. Any plea agreement must be approved by the judge.
Related Case Results
Results from William Proetta’s own cases involving similar charges:
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts.
Union County Robbery FAQs
Can shoplifting turn into a robbery charge?
Yes. If force is used or someone is threatened with immediate bodily injury during the theft or the immediate flight afterward, such as pushing a loss prevention employee, the charge can become second-degree robbery.
What makes robbery first degree in New Jersey?
Attempting to kill someone, purposely inflicting or attempting to inflict serious bodily injury, or being armed with, using or threatening the immediate use of a deadly weapon during the robbery.
Does the 85% rule apply to robbery?
Yes. First- and second-degree robbery are both covered by the No Early Release Act, so a prison sentence requires serving 85% before parole eligibility, plus parole supervision afterward.
Is it robbery if nothing was taken?
It can be. The statute covers conduct during an attempted theft, so force or threats used while trying to take something can support a robbery charge even if nothing was taken.
Can a robbery charge be downgraded?
In some cases. Weak evidence on the force, the weapon or the identification can support a downgrade to theft, shoplifting or simple assault. The judge must approve any plea deal.
Can a robbery conviction be expunged in New Jersey?
No. Robbery is on the list of convictions that can never be expunged under N.J.S.A. 2C:52-2. A downgrade to a theft or assault charge before conviction is usually the only way to keep expungement available later.
Is snatching a purse or phone robbery?
Not by itself. In State v. Sein, the New Jersey Supreme Court held that a sudden snatch with no struggle, injury or threat is a theft from the person, not robbery. A struggle, a push or a threat can make it robbery.
Can I get PTI for a robbery charge?
It is possible but difficult. For a first- or second-degree charge, the prosecutor must consent to the application, and admission requires a guilty plea that is held in inactive status and dismissed if the program is completed.
Talk to a Union County Robbery Lawyer
A robbery charge puts the No Early Release Act on the table from the first day, so the early stages of the case matter. William Proetta has more than 15 years of criminal trial experience defending robbery and other serious charges in Union County Superior Court. Call (908) 838-0150 for a free, confidential consultation, 24/7, or contact us online. Se habla español.