Prescription Fraud Attorney in Elizabeth, NJ

Reviewed by William A. Proetta, Esq. · Updated November 2026

Prescription fraud is charged in New Jersey under N.J.S.A. 2C:35-13, which makes it a crime to obtain a controlled dangerous substance by misrepresentation, fraud, forgery, deception or subterfuge. It is a third-degree crime with a fine of up to $50,000, higher than the usual third-degree limit. A forged or altered prescription is often also charged as third-degree forgery of a prescription blank, and the case can include drug possession charges. In Union County, prescription fraud is prosecuted in Superior Court in Elizabeth.

What the State Has to Prove

Under N.J.S.A. 2C:35-13, it is unlawful to acquire or obtain possession of a controlled dangerous substance, or a controlled substance analog, by misrepresentation, fraud, forgery, deception or subterfuge. The statute does not limit how the fraud is committed. Common examples include:

  • presenting a forged or altered prescription at a pharmacy,
  • changing the quantity or number of refills on a real prescription,
  • calling in a prescription while pretending to be a doctor or a doctor’s office,
  • using a stolen prescription pad or a doctor’s DEA number without authorization, and
  • giving false information to a doctor to obtain a prescription.

The statute also says it does not prevent a separate theft prosecution for the same conduct.

Charges that commonly arise from a single fraudulent prescription in New JerseyHow One Fake Prescription Becomes Several ChargesN.J.S.A. 2C:35-13 and related statutes. Each is a separate count.1Obtaining a CDS by fraud2C:35-13 · 3rd degree · fine upto $50,0002Forging the prescription2C:21-1 · 3rd degree for aprescription blank3Possessing the drug2C:35-10 · grade depends on thedrug and amountMandatory penaltyA $1,000 Drug Enforcement andDemand Reduction penalty for a3rd degree drug crimeNot filled?A pharmacy refusal can stilllead to an attempt chargeTreatment pathsPTI or Recovery Court are oftenrealistic outcomes for firstoffendersThird degree: 3 to 5 years, with a presumption against prison for a first offenseFine for obtaining a CDS by fraud can reach $50,000
Obtaining a CDS by fraud under N.J.S.A. 2C:35-13, forgery under 2C:21-1, possession under 2C:35-10 and the penalty under 2C:35-15.

Charges That Often Come Together

A single trip to a pharmacy with an altered prescription can produce several charges. The most common combination in Union County is obtaining a CDS by fraud, forgery of a prescription blank, and possession of the drug itself, along with attempt charges when the pharmacy refused to fill the prescription.

Union County

Prescription Fraud and Related Charges

ChargeStatuteUsual gradeWhere it is heard
Obtaining a CDS by fraud, forgery, deception or subterfuge2C:35-133rd degreeSuperior Court
Forging or altering a prescription blank2C:21-1(b)3rd degreeSuperior Court
Theft of a New Jersey prescription blank2C:20-2(b)(2)3rd degreeSuperior Court
Possession of forgery devices2C:21-1(c)3rd degreeSuperior Court
Possession of a controlled dangerous substance2C:35-10Depends on the drug and amountSuperior Court
Every charge on this list is indictable and heard in Union County Superior Court in Elizabeth.

Penalties

Obtaining a CDS by fraud carries the ordinary third-degree prison range, three to five years, but the fine can reach $50,000 instead of the usual $15,000. Because it is a drug offense under Chapter 35 of the Criminal Code, a conviction also carries a mandatory Drug Enforcement and Demand Reduction penalty, which is $1,000 for a third-degree crime. Licensed professionals, including nurses, pharmacists and pharmacy technicians, face separate licensing consequences.

Maximum sentences

New Jersey Penalties by Grade

GradeCourtJail or prisonMax fineSeverity
Petty disorderly personsMunicipal CourtUp to 30 days$500
Disorderly personsMunicipal CourtUp to 6 months$1,000
4th degreeSuperior CourtUp to 18 months$10,000
3rd degreeSuperior Court3 to 5 years$15,000
2nd degreeSuperior Court5 to 10 years$150,000
1st degreeSuperior Court10 to 20 years$200,000
Maximums under N.J.S.A. 2C:43-3, 2C:43-6 and 2C:43-8. A first-time offender convicted of a 3rd- or 4th-degree crime has a presumption against prison; 1st- and 2nd-degree crimes carry a presumption of prison.

Where Prescription Fraud Cases Come From in Union County

Most prescription fraud cases in Union County start at a pharmacy. A pharmacist who notices an unusual quantity, an unfamiliar prescriber or a prescription that does not match the state’s prescription monitoring records calls the prescriber’s office, and then the police. Others come from doctors’ offices that discover a stolen pad or a call-in made in their name, and from employers in hospitals and pharmacies. Many of these cases involve opioids such as oxycodone, or other prescription drugs such as benzodiazepines and stimulants.

Treatment and Diversion

Many people charged with prescription fraud are dealing with a substance use problem that began with a legitimate prescription. That history matters. First offenders are often considered for PTI, and people with a substance use disorder may be eligible for Recovery Court, which pairs supervised treatment with the criminal case. Showing early engagement in treatment can make a real difference in how a prosecutor and a judge view the case.

Defending a Prescription Fraud Charge

  • A valid prescription. A legitimate prescription that a pharmacy questioned is not fraud. Prescriber records often resolve this.
  • No knowledge. A person who picked up a prescription for someone else may not have known it was altered.
  • Identification. Call-in prescriptions and pharmacy pickups are often tied to a person only by a name or a phone number.
  • Statements at the pharmacy. What was said to a pharmacist or an officer, and whether Miranda warnings were required, can affect the case.
  • Treatment-based resolutions. PTI, Recovery Court and downgrades are often realistic outcomes, especially for a first offense.

Any plea agreement must be approved by the judge.

Related Case Results

Results from William Proetta’s own cases involving similar charges:

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case depends on its own facts.

Union County Prescription Fraud FAQs

What is the charge for a fake prescription in New Jersey?

Usually obtaining a controlled dangerous substance by fraud under N.J.S.A. 2C:35-13, a third-degree crime, often with forgery of a prescription blank, also third degree.

What is the fine for prescription fraud?

Up to $50,000, higher than the usual $15,000 limit for a third-degree crime, plus a mandatory $1,000 Drug Enforcement and Demand Reduction penalty.

Is it a crime if the pharmacy did not fill the prescription?

It can be charged as an attempt. An attempt is generally graded the same as the crime that was attempted.

Can I be charged for picking up a prescription for someone else?

Only if you knew it was fraudulent. Knowledge is often the main issue in these cases.

Can I get PTI for prescription fraud?

Many first offenders are considered for PTI, often with a treatment requirement.

What is Recovery Court?

A supervised treatment program in Superior Court for people whose charges are connected to a substance use disorder. It can be an alternative to a prison sentence.

Will a nurse or pharmacist lose their license?

Licensing boards treat drug and fraud charges seriously, and the resolution of the criminal case often affects the licensing outcome.

Can a prescription fraud conviction be expunged?

Prescription fraud is not on the list of offenses that can never be expunged.

Talk to a Union County Prescription Fraud Lawyer

Prescription fraud cases often have a treatment-based path to a resolution. William Proetta has more than 15 years of criminal trial experience and defends prescription fraud charges in municipal courts across Union County and in Superior Court in Elizabeth. Call (908) 838-0150 for a free, confidential consultation, available 24/7, or contact us online. Se habla español.