Insurance Fraud Attorney in Hudson County
Reviewed by William A. Proetta, Esq. · Updated October 2026
Insurance fraud under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6 is a third-degree crime, three to five years and up to $15,000, for a single knowingly false statement of material fact in an insurance claim, application or related document. It becomes a second-degree crime, five to ten years with a presumption of prison, when the State proves five or more separate acts and at least $1,000 in benefits obtained or sought. A criminal case is brought by the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office or by the State’s Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor and is heard in the Criminal Division of Hudson County Superior Court, located in the Frank J. Guarini Justice Complex at 24 Central Avenue near Journal Square. A separate civil penalty track runs alongside it and does not require a conviction.
These cases can begin long before an arrest, with a recorded statement to a carrier’s special investigations unit or an examination under oath, and what you say in that interview can become an “act” the State charges. I have represented people in Hudson County fraud investigations for more than 15 years, and whether to give that statement can matter more than anything later in the courtroom. Call (201) 793-8018 for a free, confidential case review.
Insurance Fraud Under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6
The State must prove that you knowingly made, or caused to be made, a false, fictitious, fraudulent or misleading statement of material fact, or knowingly omitted a material fact, in a record, bill, claim or other document, in writing, electronically or orally, that was submitted or that you attempted to submit in one of four settings:
- A claim for payment, reimbursement or benefits under a policy, from an insurer or from the Unsatisfied Claim and Judgment Fund.
- An application to obtain or renew a policy.
- A payment made or to be made under a policy or a premium finance transaction.
- An affidavit, certification, record or other document used in any insurance or premium finance transaction.
The carrier does not have to have paid, or even to have been fooled. In State v. Goodwin, 224 N.J. 102, 115 (2016), the Supreme Court held that an insured can be convicted though the carrier was never induced to pay, so long as the misstatement was knowing and material: the fact could reasonably have affected the insurer’s decision. A separate subsection creates an inference that a person who signed or initialed a document read it, which is how paperwork prepared by someone else can be attributed to the signer.
Out-of-state garaging. Subsection (b) is a fourth-degree crime, up to 18 months, for a New Jersey resident who insures a vehicle principally garaged here under an out-of-state policy by misrepresenting residence or garaging. A truthfully disclosed second residence or school address is an exception.
How Insurance Fraud Is Graded
Insurance fraud: the number of acts and the actor set the grade
N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6 (insurance fraud) and 2C:21-4.3 (health care claims fraud). Bars span the ordinary prison range on a 0 to 10 year scale.
A non-practitioner who commits five or more acts of health care claims fraud totaling $1,000 or more is also second degree. Indictable offenses are screened by the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office before the Criminal Division of Superior Court (24 Central Avenue, Jersey City) hears them.
Counting to five. Each act is a separate offense, five or more may be aggregated, and the current text of subsection (c) says that multiple acts contained in a single record each count. State v. Fleischman, 189 N.J. 539 (2007), read the statute more narrowly: a single document or oral narrative about one claim was one act, and three false statements about one stolen-car claim could not be stacked into five. The model charge adds that statements in one narrative can be separate acts if they concern a conceptually distinct claim, and that separate documents about one claim can each be an act. Whether Fleischman‘s single-document rule survives the “single record” language in the current statute is something we confirm in every five-act case. The State’s path to five is usually separate submissions: the loss report, the recorded statement, the proof-of-loss form, the supplemental estimate and the examination under oath.
Health care claims fraud under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.2 and 4.3 is the parallel statute for medical, chiropractic and dental billing. For a licensed practitioner acting knowingly it is second degree for each violation with no dollar threshold, and a conviction can cost the professional license: a licensing board may suspend or revoke a license for a crime related to the regulated profession under N.J.S.A. 45:1-21(f). The fine can reach five times the benefit obtained or sought, which in a PIP billing case can far exceed the ordinary $150,000 cap. Billing for treatment without assessing the patient, or for more procedures than the time allowed, supports an inference of knowledge.
How many separate false statements does the State allege?
N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6(c). The number of “acts” decides whether insurance fraud is a third- or second-degree crime. Use the buttons to see the line.
An “act” is a knowingly false, fictitious or misleading statement of material fact, or a material omission, in connection with a claim, an application, a payment or an insurance document. Each separate act is a separate offense; health care claims fraud acts under 2C:21-4.2 count toward the five. A judge may dismiss a de minimis case under 2C:2-11.
The Civil Penalty Track Under N.J.S.A. 17:33A-5
New Jersey runs two systems against the same conduct. Under the Insurance Fraud Prevention Act, the Commissioner of Banking and Insurance can bring a civil action or impose an administrative penalty of up to $5,000 for a first violation, $10,000 for a second and $15,000 for each violation after that, plus restitution to the insurer, costs and attorney’s fees, and a referral to any professional licensing board. The burden is lighter than in a criminal case, and the civil case can proceed whether or not charges are filed. The statute allows a consent agreement to bar its use in later proceedings, so whether it can be used in the criminal case depends on its wording, and criminal counsel should review it before signing.
Insurance Fraud Cases in Jersey City, Hoboken and Hudson County
The cases take a few familiar shapes. Staged and “jump-in” collisions on Route 440, Kennedy Boulevard and the Holland Tunnel approach can produce PIP claims for passengers who were never in the car, with treatment billed by a clinic lined up in advance; those cases can sweep in the passengers, the runner and the providers together. Garaging charges are a second category. The rest are individual claims: a car reported stolen after it was sold, a pre-existing dent added to a Hoboken garage claim, or a Bergenline Avenue storefront’s inflated loss.
The Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor was created by the Automobile Insurance Cost Reduction Act of 1998 (P.L.1998, c.21) inside the Division of Criminal Justice. It coordinates criminal insurance fraud enforcement statewide and works with county prosecutors, including the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office and its Special Investigations Unit. By the time a detective asks for “your side,” the carrier file and any recorded statements may already be in hand, and the interview can be used to add an act.
PTI in Insurance Fraud Cases
The PTI question here is the act count. A third- or fourth-degree charge follows the terms on our Pretrial Intervention page, with restitution to the carrier and a civil resolution with the Department of Banking and Insurance as likely conditions. A five-act second-degree charge begins with the presumption against admission described there, so the practical route to diversion is first getting the act count below five.
Arrest and Pretrial Release
Because many insurance fraud cases are charged after a long investigation, a complaint-summons or an invitation to surrender is possible. Whether a complaint-warrant issues depends on the complaint, and ring and provider cases with many defendants are where a pretrial release hearing is most likely. Detention requires a motion and a hearing in any case.
Immigration Consequences
Take a passenger in a PIP ring who pleads to a third-degree count and receives probation. Insurance fraud is generally treated as a crime involving moral turpitude because deceit is an element. The sharper line is 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(43)(M)(i): a fraud offense in which the loss to the victim exceeds $10,000 is an aggravated felony regardless of the sentence, so a probationary plea is still a removal problem if the restitution order or plea colloquy puts the loss above that figure. Where the facts allow, the loss in the plea and the restitution order should stay at or under $10,000.
Defenses to Insurance Fraud Charges
- Knowledge. A wrong date, a forgotten prior claim or an address a broker filled in is not insurance fraud unless the State proves you knew it was false when submitted.
- Materiality. Under Goodwin the fact must be one that could reasonably have affected the insurer’s decision. An error no reasonable carrier would care about does not meet the element.
- Act counting. Forcing the State to identify five separate, knowing, material acts is the central fight in a second-degree case. Fleischman supports treating one document or narrative about one claim as one act, subject to the qualifiers above, and a win returns the case to third degree.
- Garaging facts. For a subsection (b) charge, a documented second residence, a student address or an out-of-state job assignment, truthfully disclosed, falls within the statutory exception.
- Who made the statement. The signature inference is permissive. Paperwork prepared by a public adjuster, billing office or runner is attributed to the signer only if the jury accepts it.
- The recorded statement and EUO. Where investigators directed a carrier’s questioning, there may be grounds to challenge how the statement was obtained in a suppression motion.
Insurance fraud runs on two tracks, and both can run at once
N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6 (criminal) and N.J.S.A. 17:33A-5, the Insurance Fraud Prevention Act (civil). A dismissal on one track does not end the other.
Criminal · N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6
- Who: the Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor in the Division of Criminal Justice, or the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office.
- Grade: third degree (3 to 5 years, up to $15,000); second degree with five or more acts and $1,000 or more in aggregate (5 to 10 years, up to $150,000).
- Burden: beyond a reasonable doubt, before a jury in Superior Court.
- Result: a criminal record, possible prison, restitution, and immigration and licensing consequences.
Civil · N.J.S.A. 17:33A-5
- Who: the Commissioner of Banking and Insurance, by civil action or administrative penalty.
- Penalty: up to $5,000 for a first violation, $10,000 for a second, and $15,000 for each violation after that.
- Plus: restitution to the insurer or injured party, costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees, and referral to professional licensing boards.
- Result: no jail and no criminal record, but a judgment that follows you and that insurers can see.
A statement must be knowingly false and material to count on either track. In the criminal case the insurer does not have to have been induced to pay (State v. Goodwin, 224 N.J. 102 (2016)).
Insurance Fraud FAQs
Is insurance fraud a felony in New Jersey?
New Jersey calls the offenses crimes rather than felonies. Under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6 it is at least a third-degree crime, and a second-degree crime at five or more acts and $1,000. Only the out-of-state garaging offense is fourth degree.
Can I be charged if the insurance company never paid the claim?
Yes. The statute covers claims submitted or attempted, and State v. Goodwin, 224 N.J. 102 (2016), confirms a conviction does not require that the carrier was induced to pay.
What counts as five acts of insurance fraud?
Five separate knowingly false, material statements. Under State v. Fleischman, 189 N.J. 539 (2007), one document or narrative about a single claim was one act, though separate documents and conceptually distinct claims can count separately.
Is registering my car in another state to save on insurance a crime in NJ?
If you live in New Jersey and the car is principally garaged here, misrepresenting your residence or garaging to obtain an out-of-state policy is a fourth-degree crime under N.J.S.A. 2C:21-4.6(b), and it can also bring civil penalties.
Who prosecutes insurance fraud in Hudson County?
The Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office or the State’s Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor, which coordinates statewide enforcement with county prosecutors.
Should I talk to the insurance investigator?
Not before speaking with counsel. Recorded statements and examinations under oath are where many charged acts originate, and a cooperation clause in the policy can be addressed through a lawyer.
Talk to a Hudson County Insurance Fraud Lawyer
The line between third and second degree is often drawn by what was said in the first interview, so the time to call is before the interview. If a carrier’s investigator, the Department of Banking and Insurance or the Office of the Insurance Fraud Prosecutor has contacted you about a claim in Jersey City, Hoboken or anywhere in Hudson County, call William Proetta Criminal Law at (201) 793-8018 for a free, confidential review, or contact us online.